Skip to main content


"Can you explain the "forced ranking" system (e.g. GE style) that the Big 4 use to weed out employees. I'm about to join a Big 4 and want to know how to survive this."

Good question. There are really three factors that come into play here -
a) CPA - This is huge. If you don't have it after 4 years at your firm, you're in the red zone. Try and get it out of the way as soon as you become eligible to take it. If you are not a good test taker, then it is even more imperative to begin the arduous process asap. If you are an audit superstar, but still don't have your CPA by this time, you're in danger. Why? Because it is a numbers game, and since firms have to cut a certain number, they just look at stats and don't look at each individual's particular scenario.
b) Performance Reviews - Don't aim for an average rating. In this economy, it's not good enough. Yes, if people know you're good, you might end up getting put on horrendous clients. But that's just a risk you have to take. Take more responsibility for what you do. Help your senior associate/manager in any which way you can. Trust me, he or she will really appreciate your willingness to help (assistance, not brown-nosing). If you go below average w/ different reviewers, update your resume.
c) Hours - If you're sitting around in the office "on the bench" and not working much for days/weeks, don't wait for somebody to assign you to certain clients. Go seek out your managers/senior associates and ask to be put on clients. This is a very easy metric for HR to measure, and if they notice that you're not being used effectively, you're expendable.Then again, if people start leaving the firms, then they'd go back to the pre-recession days of their economic model, i.e. constantly be short of auditors instead of having an excess to carry around on their books.


Anonymous said…
Anonymous said…
Seek out work?!?! Screw that! Auditors are underpaid and overworked compared to their commerce counterparts (in Australia). When you are benched and have downtime, milk it for all it's worth.

Surely with the natural attrition rate in audit, your job is safe.
Anonymous said…
I would agree. It's interesting that at our firm there are so many people that are concerned about losing their jobs. That's why you become an accountant! The job security! I mean, sure, you might get thrown off of the Big 4 bus, but to think that you'll be forced to join the ranks of the unemployed for any significant period of time is delusional.
Anonymous said…
i agree! i would be out of my mind to tell the staff planner i am free. that's so crazy. i can imagine, once they hear that, work will get piled on you so much that you will regret ever offering help.
notfordisplay said…
Good luck trying to stay under the radar. Given that it's a numbers game, your chargeable hours also play a role in your survival at the firm. Roll the dice.
Anonymous said…
I am glad I was fired from Big 4 auditing. You learn nothing applicable to real businesses and even so your knowledge is limited. Auditors do not even know how to make up the companys records because they cannot use bookkeeping software or many of the entries made which is shameful. This is not practical either. Small firm accounting is less hours, less stressful and more knowledgable. You are more marketable out of a small firm than a big firm. Not bitter, just saying. Everyone is brainwashed. Bigger is not better.

Popular posts from this blog

auditing vs consulting

I was wondering if you could break down the career opportunities in auditing and consulting (in a big 4). I know that consulting pays more in a big 4 and has more interesting work, but it seems that auditing has extremely good exit opportunities (Financial controller, CFO etc). Any thoughts on which is better in the long run?

Well there's different consulting services offered by public accounting companies - the most popular being IT consulting and risk consulting. There are also other consulting services offered, but these two hire the most. Do they pay more? Yes, but not by much. Not enough for you to say: Shoot, the $$ is a huge reason for me to move over. Is the work more interesting than audit? Yes. You're actually looking over a company's processes and telling them what to do instead of what not to do (audit). Everyone I know who's made the switch likes it waay better than audit.
In the long run though, choosing audit vs consulting really depends on what you want t…

should you choose to audit financial services?

I'm trying to decide whether to audit financial services companies or non-financial services companies. What would you say are the pros and cons of either industries? Do individuals who choose non-FS have less career mobility within the firm or if they decide not to stay with the B4 after a few years?
Really depends on what you'd like to do after (unless you really love auditing). If you want to a controller,etc. at a p/e firm or a hedge fund down the road, you'd want to go into financial services. The pay won't be too bad, especially if you get a share of the insane bonuses they dole out. If you want to audit industries with tangible products and want to get a better understanding of the operations of such businesses, then other industries are the way to go.In terms of mobility outside the firm, auditing other industries is the way to go since you have plenty of options when you exit the audit world. For example, in 2008, after Lehman collapsed, it was incredibly hard …

Should I leave after 2 years as senior?

I'm currently working in KPMG Philippines, will about to start my fourth busy season and it'll be my second year as a supervisor/senior. I would like to know if it'll be a good idea to go work for a private company by this time. My only concern is that work outside audit may not be as enjoyable for me. However, I am starting to get tired of too much workload. 

At this point, stay until you get a year as manager under your belt and then leave. You could leave now and start as a senior accountant somewhere only if it's not a regular operational job where you'll do the same thing every time. Over the next few years, you'll pick up a lot of soft skills and technical skills that will be critical to your growth. If your only goal is a 9-5 workday and the money isn't all that important to you, then leave now, but if you can tolerate the workload for 3 more years, stay. It'll benefit you a lot long term.