Skip to main content

reviews

What are performance reviews? They're basically a review of your performance on particular jobs, and help dictate whether you get promoted and how much your raise will be.

Man I absolutely hate writing and discussing performance reviews. When someone works with you on a three month job, you have to keep notes of key points during the 3 mth period so you can add it to the review. Then you write a two page review that ends up looking like one or two paragraphs. But you have to be real careful when writing these reviews. Odds are these individuals are going to be working with you in the future, so you don't want them being pissed off at you the whole time. You can't be too brutal in the reviews, since this might change their career path. I've reached a point where I write reviews and won't submit it for a few days, so I can re-read it and make sure it wasn't my mood at the time that dictated the review. Believe me, writing reviews can be heavily dictated by the mood you're in at the time.

Then comes the discussion part, man that's even worse. The only time people want to discuss reviews with you is when you've written a bad one. I've seen one person cry when they discussed their review with me. Then they launch into an explanation as to why they disagree with something in the review. Then you explain why you wrote what you wrote, and it ends on a somewhat amicable note, but it festers on. And then when you write really bad reviews, you duck into hallways and stairwells to avoid seeing the person you wrote a bad review for so you can avoid those awkward moments.

Oh well, at the end of the day, it's a necessary evil. I get why they are important, I just hate doing them. And I'd be willing to bet that most reviewers feel this way.

Comments

Anonymous said…
I'd like to add two things regarding the reviews:
(1) Not only does this go on the person's permanent record, it is reviewed by a panel of "independent" "confidential" parties. So, if you receive a poor review unexpectedly and that is your largest engagement, you walk the halls in constant fear that the person you speak to knows. and
(2) you see all the people you thought were friendly coworkers begin to contact you less.
In all honesty, I understand why reviews are important, however, I find that reviewers do not take into consideration all the outside components that may effect a person's performance.
Anonymous said…
I'd like to add two things regarding the reviews:
(1) Not only does this go on the person's permanent record, it is reviewed by a panel of "independent" "confidential" parties. So, if you receive a poor review unexpectedly and that is your largest engagement, you walk the halls in constant fear that the person you speak to knows. and
(2) you see all the people you thought were friendly coworkers begin to contact you less.
In all honesty, I understand why reviews are important, however, I find that reviewers do not take into consideration all the outside components that may effect a person's performance and most importantly do not take into consideration the repercussions of a negative review.
Anonymous said…
Thanks for answering all these questions. Great blog. Can you talk about why you haven't left you firm yet, thoughts on the chances/possibility/desire of becoming a partner? A buddy at a big4 and I were talking the other day how much harder it must be to make partner nowadays. Back in the SOX boom, it seemed like the road was a lot easier.

Popular posts from this blog

auditing vs consulting

I was wondering if you could break down the career opportunities in auditing and consulting (in a big 4). I know that consulting pays more in a big 4 and has more interesting work, but it seems that auditing has extremely good exit opportunities (Financial controller, CFO etc). Any thoughts on which is better in the long run?

Well there's different consulting services offered by public accounting companies - the most popular being IT consulting and risk consulting. There are also other consulting services offered, but these two hire the most. Do they pay more? Yes, but not by much. Not enough for you to say: Shoot, the $$ is a huge reason for me to move over. Is the work more interesting than audit? Yes. You're actually looking over a company's processes and telling them what to do instead of what not to do (audit). Everyone I know who's made the switch likes it waay better than audit.
In the long run though, choosing audit vs consulting really depends on what you want t…

should you choose to audit financial services?

I'm trying to decide whether to audit financial services companies or non-financial services companies. What would you say are the pros and cons of either industries? Do individuals who choose non-FS have less career mobility within the firm or if they decide not to stay with the B4 after a few years?
Really depends on what you'd like to do after (unless you really love auditing). If you want to a controller,etc. at a p/e firm or a hedge fund down the road, you'd want to go into financial services. The pay won't be too bad, especially if you get a share of the insane bonuses they dole out. If you want to audit industries with tangible products and want to get a better understanding of the operations of such businesses, then other industries are the way to go.In terms of mobility outside the firm, auditing other industries is the way to go since you have plenty of options when you exit the audit world. For example, in 2008, after Lehman collapsed, it was incredibly hard …

Should I leave after 2 years as senior?

I'm currently working in KPMG Philippines, will about to start my fourth busy season and it'll be my second year as a supervisor/senior. I would like to know if it'll be a good idea to go work for a private company by this time. My only concern is that work outside audit may not be as enjoyable for me. However, I am starting to get tired of too much workload. 

At this point, stay until you get a year as manager under your belt and then leave. You could leave now and start as a senior accountant somewhere only if it's not a regular operational job where you'll do the same thing every time. Over the next few years, you'll pick up a lot of soft skills and technical skills that will be critical to your growth. If your only goal is a 9-5 workday and the money isn't all that important to you, then leave now, but if you can tolerate the workload for 3 more years, stay. It'll benefit you a lot long term.