Skip to main content

Why is private better than public?

"Could you elaborate, why your life is better now?"

Here are some of the various differences between public and private-

a) The work itself - The work is significantly better. In public, you spend half your time on documentation and controls. That's all essentially Cover Your Ass work so the PCAOB or your internal reviews don't deem it to be a deficient audit. You're essentially trying to figure out ways to say that you are comfortable with your client's work. While you get a high level overview of the various processes, you don't really dig into it or have the power to change things. In private, you're actually making decisions - whether it comes to accounting conclusions or process improvements, and what you prepare or review actually makes it into our financials. Yes - we're not the revenue generators, but there is something more intangible in coming up with the financials than reviewing it once it's done.

b) On call - In audit, you're always on call. If a client calls you on a weekend, you answer. You're always checking your phones at night and making sure you have substantive responses in case your team or the client emails. And when there's offerings, forget about it. In private, unless it's during monthly close or whatever, you're generally in good shape in the evenings or weekends. You likely won't even be receiving emails (unless there's an imminent deal or offering), and even if you do, the expectation is that you will only respond on Monday or when you're back.

c) Vacations - In Private, vacations are vacations. People rarely bother you when you're out. In audit, at a certain point in your career, you don't really have work-free vacations. Goes back to b), in a sense, you're always on call.

d) Not being hated - Auditors are a necessary evil, and no group in the Company really likes dealing with the auditors. I was fine with it as an auditor, but there are always conflicts. Client service is a misnomer with the PCAOB breathing down the auditors' necks. It sucks when you're trying to push the Company to do something that you think is a waste but needs to be done so we can cover ourselves from a bad rating. 

d) Bonuses and pay - The bonuses in Public aren't much, it just isn't. The Firms make it up by increasing the base by 10-15% every year, but it's still an absolute pittance. In Private, the bonuses are where it's at. It's a great feeling when you find out about your annual bonuses (until you see the after-tax numbers, but that's a different conversation). Yea sure, the base pay usually doesn't increase that much in most companies, but I would argue that if you're good, it will increase since the Companies would want to keep you. It's not like a factory model where they can spit you out and hire another one to replace you immediately.

e) Stability - After a certain age, you'd probably not want to be placed on random engagements in the middle of nowhere, or have a small sense of uncertainty if there are open slots in your schedule for whatever reason - your existing client got bought out, the Company moves to another location to cut costs, etc. etc. In Private, you go to the same location essentially every day. While that gets boring when you're young, it's something you will appreciate as you get older.

Exceptions...
There are two things that I miss from Public - 

a) Back office - Accounting in Private is the back office unfortunately. So we're not the drivers of major decisions for the Company, and just have to deal with what the Company does from an accounting standpoint. In Public, the auditors are essentially the front office, although it doesn't really feel that way.

b) Flexibility - While you can get flexibility in Private, it's nothing like the flexibility you get after a certain level in Public. Once you have self-sufficient teams doing the day to day work on various engagements, you can basically work from home a good of time, or take days off here and there for various errands. You know you're going to working like a dog on random days anyway, so enjoy this flexibility.





Comments

Himani Sharma said…
The post is written in very a good manner and it entails many useful information for me. I appreciated what you have done here. I am always searching for informative information like this. Thanks for sharing with us.
rohan said…
Enjoyed reading your blog,you have touched various aspects of an auditor.Very useful information for people like us who want to be a auditor.I would suggest you to go to http://www.lacaco.com/ were you can find many Auditors,you can contact them for any queries or suggestion for future career growth.
Violet M said…
Thank you for the information! http://estates.uonbi.ac.ke/
Abhilasha said…
This is a nice article. There is so much you have mentioned where so much can be learned. Thanks for the information!!!

shiwani said…
Thanks for your posting .
Keep posting like this is very helpful For us
I have found something new in this Article.
Interior designer
shruti said…
This is a very informative and helpful post, very honest and practical advise. Thank you so much for a detailed post. It's very helpful for all .Specially this complete information will be helping to all. Thanks!
www.neerajbhagat.com
Ritu said…
I recently found your page and so far I love it. Keep up the good work. You have done an excellent job with your writing.
Chartered accountant: www.raaas.com
Niharika said…
Really impressive post. I read it whole and going to share it with my social circules. I enjoyed your article.
Thanks for sharing this great article.
Sachin said…
It is in reality a great and helpful piece of information. I’m satisfied that you simply shared this helpful info with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

Popular posts from this blog

ADP/Payroll

Just realized that the very payroll/adp reports we all enjoyed looking at in order to see how much our client contacts made, now seem to piss me off. Especially when your main contact, who couldn't tell a debit from a credit, makes significantly more than you, and leaves at 5. It's almost guaranteed to get you in a foul mood and yak with your team about the ridiculous salaries that certain employees get when compared to yours.

should you choose to audit financial services?

I'm trying to decide whether to audit financial services companies or non-financial services companies. What would you say are the pros and cons of either industries? Do individuals who choose non-FS have less career mobility within the firm or if they decide not to stay with the B4 after a few years? Really depends on what you'd like to do after (unless you really love auditing). If you want to a controller,etc. at a p/e firm or a hedge fund down the road, you'd want to go into financial services. The pay won't be too bad, especially if you get a share of the insane bonuses they dole out. If you want to audit industries with tangible products and want to get a better understanding of the operations of such businesses, then other industries are the way to go.In terms of mobility outside the firm, auditing other industries is the way to go since you have plenty of options when you exit the audit world. For example, in 2008, after Lehman collapsed, it was incredibly hard

auditing vs consulting

I was wondering if you could break down the career opportunities in auditing and consulting (in a big 4). I know that consulting pays more in a big 4 and has more interesting work, but it seems that auditing has extremely good exit opportunities (Financial controller, CFO etc). Any thoughts on which is better in the long run? Well there's different consulting services offered by public accounting companies - the most popular being IT consulting and risk consulting. There are also other consulting services offered, but these two hire the most. Do they pay more? Yes, but not by much. Not enough for you to say: Shoot, the $$ is a huge reason for me to move over. Is the work more interesting than audit? Yes. You're actually looking over a company's processes and telling them what to do instead of what not to do (audit). Everyone I know who's made the switch likes it waay better than audit. In the long run though, choosing audit vs consulting really depends on what you want